Made with four cheeses, the Icon Grill’s Ultimate Macaroni and Cheese is a gooey, crusty-topped bowl of tasty goodness. The culinary masterpiece arrived at our table steaming hot and topped with finely chopped tomatoes, but what happened next really sent me over the edge. Our waiter, who told us that the dish was the restaurant’s top-selling item for about a decade, poured a huge glob of melted cheese right on top.

This is what I call good-nasty. Grab a fork and call the paramedics.